disputation

The bounds of the disputation are up to the disputants.

Finally, he appeals to open discussion in a way that welcomes disagreement and sincere disputation of any points he makes.

Similarly, the disputation of these facts can be pedantic quibbling or interesting and informative.

If the system is open to disputation, feedback, analysis, etc. while pursuing the widest possible range of views out there from under-represented voices, then great.

" There are indeed individuals for whom this sort of disputation is a career, or at least vocation, regardless of how cynical or innocent their intentions may be.

Instead it attempts to quantify the process of hypothesis and disputation in an open-ended way—yet an intuitive one, which attempts to interface with the ways that a professional will already think about a problem.

Liebniz's "art of infallibility" is of course about the proof verification/checking, as the full quote makes clear:"if controversies were to arise, there would be no more need of disputation between two philosophers than between two calculators.

In both hiring and tenure review, even the best programs still struggle to include analysis beyond traditional western civ style work.> If it means preventing disputation on the basis of a person's identity/affiliations, disavowing empiricism and heavily favoring narrative untethered to basic standards of evidence, inserting overt agenda into what ought to be neutral arms-length investigationsIt doesn't.